For sound waves, if the number of nodes for the harmonic of an open-ended pipe is and that for the harmonic of the same pipe with one of its ends closed is , the ratio is
- A.
- B.
- C.
- D.
- Recall that in an open pipe (open at both ends), every harmonic — 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and so on — is allowed, and the number of nodes formed always equals the harmonic number itself.
Given the pipe supports the 5th harmonic,
- Recall that in a pipe closed at one end, only odd harmonics (1st, 3rd, 5th, 7th, 9th, ...) can exist, and each successive odd harmonic adds one more node than the previous one.
Counting nodes for successive odd harmonics: 1st harmonic → 1 node, 3rd harmonic → 2 nodes, 5th harmonic → 3 nodes, 7th harmonic → 4 nodes, 9th harmonic → 5 nodes.
Therefore, for the 9th harmonic,
- Since both and are now known, find their ratio.
Hence,
Hence, the answer is D.